
But then came the voice of one of the criminals. Like a crack of thunder! So unexpected! So shocking! Rebuking his compatriot in crime. “Don’t you fear God, since you are under the same condemnation? We are punished justly, for we are receiving what we deserve for what we have done, but this man has done nothing wrong.” (Luke 23:40-41)
This is true repentance! This thief offers no excuse for his conduct. There's no playing the victim card, no attempt to blame anyone else for what he was, neither his parents nor his partner nor his peers. Instead, this thief makes a candid admission that he's getting exactly what he deserves. His problem is with himself, not with his environment. He knows he is a sinner, and he confesses it openly before all. He’s sorry for what he has done; not sorry about the consequences in his own life and how it’s hurting him, but he’s sorry for what he’s done to hurt other people. Sorry for the way he’s hurt his God. This is repentance.
"We are punished justly, for we are receiving what we deserve for what we have done." (verse 41). Out of the mouth of a common—or perhaps I should say “uncommon”—thief comes a powerful and profound confession that each of us needs to make our own! For this thief came to see himself as God sees all of us. Our God dared to write, “There is surely not a righteous man on earth who does good and does not sin. (Ecclesiastes 7:20) But that’s a hard truth to make personal, isn’t it? That’s a truth we’d much rather apply to the televangelist with his wet hanky in hand or the politician sort of apologizing into the camera or the brazen criminal caught dead to rights but still blaming society. It is so easy for us to pontificate about the evils of others around us, but to take God’s law as a mirror and look deep into our own heart, our mind, our soul? That we’d rather not do, and even when we try, we easily start excusing ourselves again. Too often we tend to grade sins on a scale ranging from not so bad to really bad. Really bad? That’s the other guy. Not so bad. That’s me. No, we're not perfect, but no one is. We’re doing the best we can. God will have to be satisfied.
But that’s not repentance, is it? True repentance admits as did the thief: “We are punished justly, for we are receiving what we deserve for what we have done.” True repentance isn’t too proud to borrow a line from the hymn as confession: “Nothing in my hand I bring, simply to thy cross I cling" (CW 389:3).
Yet true repentance is more than acknowledging sin. Even Judas did that. But unlike Judas, the thief placed his full trust in Jesus. He knew that Jesus had done nothing wrong, and he said so. Then, when eternity stared him in the face, the thief simply said, “Jesus, remember me when you come in your kingdom.” (verse 42). What did the thief want Jesus to remember? His rap sheet? I doubt it. I suspect he’d just as soon have the Lord lose that. What did the thief want Jesus to remember? His life filled with accomplishments? His good name and reputation? He had none, remember? He had nothing to offer Jesus. Nothing at all. His only hope? Jesus the Savior, the One sent to save people from their sins. This repentant thief placed every ounce of his trust in Jesus!
And with the gates of hell about to slam shut on this wretch of a man, what did Jesus do? Did he say, “Don’t bother me now. I’m hurting too much to help you.” Did Jesus say, “I’ll think about it. But I don’t know if I even want to remember the likes of you.” Did Jesus say, “I’ll try. But being God isn’t easy. There will be lots of names to remember on the Judgment Day. I’m not sure yours will make the cut.” NO! What did Jesus say? “Amen I tell you: Today you will be with me in paradise.” (Luke 23:43)
This is the purest, sweetest Gospel, isn’t it? The man asked for a scrap of grace, to be remembered somehow, some way on the Judgment Day. What did Jesus give him? A feast! A guarantee not just to be remembered, but to be with Jesus! To be with the Savior off of that horrible cross that same day—free from pain, sorrow, punishment, and sin! Forever in paradise!
Treasure this Gospel, knowing this: that thief on the cross, that might as well be you or me. But you argue, “Pastor, I’ve never gone to court, been tried and convicted. I’ve never cooled my heels in the Oneida or Vilas County Jail much less a state prison.” Maybe so. But we have been convicted in God's court, a court that has decreed, “All have sinned!” A court that passed sentence, “The soul who sins is the one who will die.” (Ezekiel 18:20) True repentance faces the facts as presented in God’s Word and doesn’t shrug them off. Instead, when we’re repentant, we say, “Yes, Lord. You got me dead to rights. I know I’ve sinned. Take me away. I deserve it.”
But then, by the grace of God the Holy Spirit working a miracle in our heart, true repentance causes us to take an incredible leap of faith. In simple trust, like the thief on the cross, we turn to Jesus and beg, “Remember me."
And what will Jesus do? Fellow felons, to us Jesus makes this grace-filled guarantee: "You will be with me in paradise."
Privileged to serve,
Rev. Glenn Schwanke
PS: Our midweek Lenten theme this year is “Reflections on Repentance.” In these services, each Wednesday at 4 pm, we are doing a deep-dive study of David’s penitential Psalm 51. The services are led by a rotation of WELS pastors from the area.